India versus America: Battle of the Youth

As appeared in the Diamondback, University of Maryland’s independent student newspaper.

  I spent my growing years in India; then, I moved here to America for college. One of the most critical benefits of this dual experience has been engaging with diverse groups of people on both sides of the world—and understanding how they think. Armed with this unique perspective, I bring signal of warning to all you folks: be wary of young people in India. They can disrupt your future.

  The case for being wary of India has strong merits: India, the world’s largest democracy, is also home to the world’s largest English-speaking population. As the world has globalized, so has India’s presence and prominence. For instance, the highest-earning demographic in the Maryland-Virginia-DC area itself, where you live, is Indians. These were the people who came to North America and flourished in the pool of opportunities here. Imagine what will happen (to you) if the land of India becomes that pool of opportunity. Today, Her youth have become global citizens with sharp quantitative skills—engineering is the nation’s third language after Hindi and English—that can drain American brainpower out of competition. Are young Americans prepared to face the tropical Indian storm heading their way? I don’t think so.

  At the outset, the best American students—argumentative, risk-taking, driven, broad-minded, with global viewpoints and diverse networks—out smart their counterparts in India by leagues. But these ultra-smart people comprise of a very small percentage of the entire American youth. To make things worse, the reverse holds true for the larger average: average young Indians—hard working, motivated, less party-quotient, etc.—outcompete their average American counterparts on most fronts required in today’s predominantly IT based job-market. And they don’t charge as much either—$6000 per annum for an engineering graduate is considered a decent salary. India’s competitive advantage is therefore young people producing work at par at much lower costs.

  Yet, India’s biggest shortfall, and reason for reprieve in America, is that young Indians have an extremely low satisfaction threshold. The journey from no wealth to some wealth is seen as the benchmark for success. Unimaginative conventionalism is all it takes to reach ‘somewhere,’ and people are happy with that as of now. And while that’s justified at the micro level, it does not serve India’s macro aspirations well. That kind of mid-way complacency disables Indians’ potential to leverage on their otherwise sharp killer instincts.

  In fact a friend of mine from one of India’s most prestigious engineering colleges, IIT Mumbai, now studying at Johns Hopkins for a semester, told me that less than 15 students applied for a subsidized, semester-long, study abroad program to the United States—out of a class of 3000 of India’s brightest minds. Clearly, learning, going out of comfort zone, and taking risks is not on any Indian agenda, at least for the time being.

  But now that young Indians are beginning to reach somewhere, the ambition of their future goals will only increase in size. It is only a matter of time that they will begin to rise above conventionalism and embrace learning and risk-taking opportunities in the process—I experienced that first-hand this winter on a train journey with 400 of India’s brightest young entrepreneurs. The innovative spirit is already beginning to percolate, and soon will flood through the minds of a significant proportion of the general young populace. When that happens, the unprepared partying American youth will be hit hard.

6 thoughts on “India versus America: Battle of the Youth”

  1. After being in the same boat as you are Anand, this is what I find hard to digest:
    Apart from all the monetary and intelligence factors of this article, this is what I have witnessed in person:

    Young Indians, with infinite potential, are governed by a “western” lifestyle. By “western”, I mean alcohol, intoxication, loss of our own rich culture.

    On the other hand, I find young Americans embracing the very values we are forgetting.

    Until this realization dawns upon us, we continue to dig our own hole.

  2. Very interesting and mature reading Anand ….I feel we should not compare American and Indian youths at all . They live in entirely different world and face entirely different problems….. Indian youth looks more luckier …. they have ample opportunities to innovate and solve day to day real problems :)

  3. I think this is extremely well-written and makes some great points. I especially connect to the realization that the Indian youth is satisfied by landing a decent job and climbing up the corporate ladder. As I write this though, I realize that the story is not much different here in New York (I am a student at NYU).

    Our strength though, lies in the endless opportunities back at home (I am from Mumbai) and that’s what we should capitalize on.


Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s